Wrapper: Corojo / Nicaragua
Binder: Undisclosed
Filler: Undisclosed
Size: Toro
Strength: Medium (barely)
Body: Medium → Medium-plus (halfway)
Price: $14
Factory: Rodríguez Santana & Co. Cigars
Blender: Chris Moore / Santos Santana
Smoking Time: 1:50
Experience Rating: 98

I love doing blind reviews.

It’s just me and the cigar. No preconceptions, no expectations. I sit with the cigar and let it tell me its story. Well… unless I’m not much of a fan of the brand. I went into the Cohiba Rubicon with plenty of skepticism.

But not in this case.

I love Carolina Blue. I’ve smoked a few of Chris Moore’s blends, and none have missed with me yet. This one came in a sample pack I purchased. All Chris told me was that it was the Nicaraguan Corojo Small Batch. Normally, I’d pick a maker’s brain for blend stats, pricing, and availability. I may still do that before I publish, but first I want to finish my evaluation. It’s Friday, and I want to have some fun with this. So let’s see what’s what.

One thing I’ve come to appreciate about Carolina Blue cigars is the attention to aesthetics and construction. The Corojo is tightly rolled, with barely visible seams. It’s packed solid and gives very little when I gently squeeze it.

The oils on the toothy wrapper glisten in the sun. In my hand, I notice the cigar’s heft. Chris didn’t skimp on tobacco with this one.

I bring the wrapper to my nose. Whoa! It’s stinky, with a Roquefort funk and a musty, grassy barnyard smell. I imagine this is what someone’s feet would smell like after hiking a few miles to a farm, taking off their shoes, and running barefoot through the barnyard. I know the imagery might seem unpleasant, but that smell is a good sign to me. The foot, on the other hand, smells of dried apricot, orange zest, and honey, a striking contrast to the funky wrapper.

I punch the cap. The draw is a little snug but not plugged, confirming how densely packed the cigar is. The cold draw is malty, laced with dry grass and cedar.

Before I light it, I chuckle. I hate writing about the pre-light inspection. Saliva runs from the corners of my mouth at the thought of that first puff (not really, but you get the point). But I need to be thorough.

I finally light the cigar, take a puff, and WOW! The dark start takes me by surprise. I get dark-roasted cacao nibs, burnt cedar, and black pepper. A couple of puffs in, cream flows into the profile. Right behind it come rich Belgian coffee, malt, and a hint of nutmeg and bay leaf. The nutmeg and bay leaf are another surprise. My first thought is, how is that going to work? But it’s uncanny how well they fit with the rest of the profile.

I’m already heading to my happy place as bready elements arrive with toffee, vanilla, and roasted nuts. At this point, the profile feels like it has its shit together. By no means does it feel complete. It just feels composed and structured.

Just over an inch in, the profile is already resonating with me. There’s little movement at this point, but the complexity and sophistication of the flavors hit me viscerally. I’m totally in tune with this cigar!

The body is rich but not viscous, and the strength is barely medium. I’m thankful for that. A thick, heady Nicaraguan cigar can easily mask its own nuance. Here, the moderate body and strength give the flavors room to express themselves fully.

I’m mostly through the first half now, and I’m wondering if I can get more of these. I hope I can, because I’m loving this experience so far.

As I near the halfway mark, something strikes me as weird. There doesn’t seem to be any movement or activity, yet I can feel an incredible amount of energy in the profile. It’s like listening to the classic Pablo Cruise song Zero to Sixty in Five. I used to play that song to psych myself up before a sporting event in high school and college.

Then it hits me.

The profile has been moving the whole time, but it’s been so smooth I haven’t felt how fast it’s going. It’s like riding a maglev bullet train. You feel that initial acceleration, then you settle in and you’d swear you’re sitting still. I can’t think of a better way to describe this cigar than that Navy SEAL saying, Slow is smooth. Smooth is fast. Okay, if you need a more modern reference, Brad Pitt used the same saying in F1: The Movie.

Deeper into the second half, the body and strength haven’t wavered, but the flavors are more pronounced and intense. What’s wild is how often this cigar catches me by surprise. First it’s the nutmeg and bay leaf, then it’s the sheer speed of a profile that feels like it’s barely moving. On paper, none of that should work, but somehow it does.

A good cigar keeps you on your toes.

It can do that through transitions, through changes in emphasis, or, as in this case, by masking its movement so well that you only recognize it after the fact.

Cigars like the Definition GEN 413 and the Megilla Artisan Shofar take that last approach to the extreme. They fuck with your mind so much that you need to smoke a few before you get it. Personally, I prefer a cigar that reveals itself a little sooner.

And then there’s the spice. When you hear the word Corojo, what’s the first thing you think of? Spice. I don’t know how Chris did it, but the spice has been so light I’ve barely noticed it. I’m down to the last inch, and only now do I feel it. But it’s so thoroughly integrated that I can’t separate it from the rest of the profile.

Integrated.

That’s the word for this cigar. Everything just fits. No wild spikes. No chaos. No sudden changes in direction. The Corojo runs like a well-oiled machine. I keep coming back to that maglev train.

That imagery is important here because when you’re riding in a train that’s going 200 miles per hour, the scenery just whizzes by. You can catch glimpses of things, but they flash by so quickly you barely have time to register them. I mentioned several flavors above, but once this train got up to speed, I couldn’t pick them up anymore. And to be honest, I didn’t really care to pay that much attention to them because I’ve been simply enjoying the ride.

As the cigar winds down to the nub, strength and body haven’t increased one bit! The flavors have intensified, and the profile seems to have taken a darker turn, but I feel zero pressure from either the strength or the body. Chris told me he always aims for a consistent experience with his blends, and man, did he accomplish that with this stick. Keeping strength and body that steady all the way to the last inch takes real bunching skill. The bonchero has to know exactly where and how to place each leaf in the bunch. And Chris mentioned to me that his bonchero is one of the best he’s ever worked with. It shows.

So much for going into a blind review with no expectations. All it took was seeing Nicaragua and Corojo together, and I figured this cigar would be bold and spicy. It was neither. What I didn’t see coming was how much energy I’d feel in a cigar this smooth. Here I am at the nub, still trying to put my finger on when it picked up speed. That’s what makes me want to smoke another one. And another one.

As I said above, I hope I can get some more.


You will not find this on the CBC website. But I recommend reaching out to Chris at info@carolinabluecigars.com to see if you can get some.


Discover more from Unco B's Stogie Diary

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Welcome!

Cigars aren’t static.

They move, evolve, and reveal themselves over time.

This is a place to explore that experience—along with the people, ideas, and forces shaping the cigar world around it.

Explore the Diary!

Cigar Foundations
Cigar Reviews
Cigar Commentary

Let’s connect

Recent posts

My good friend Phil “Katman” Kohn! Read his blog!