Wrapper: San Andrés (AA+ grade) / Mexico
Binder: Costa Rica
Filler: Nicaragua: Estelí, Condega, and Jalapa
Size: Toro (6 x 52)
Strength: Medium → Medium-Plus (final third)
Body: Medium → Full (second half)
Price: $12.00 USD
Factory: AJ Fernandez, Nicaragua
Blender: AJ Fernandez
Release: Date undisclosed (Limited Production)
Smoking Time: 1:55
Experience Rating: 98

From Privada:

Swiss Roll was built around a simple question.

What if Blue Cheese grew up?

The cigar follows the same philosophy that made Blue Cheese such a cult favorite among Privada members, but pushes the concept further. Richer. Darker. More decadent.

To make it happen, Privada partnered with AJ Fernandez and built the blend around an exceptional AA+ Grade Mexican San Andrés wrapper, one of the highest classifications available from this renowned tobacco. Beneath it sits a rare Costa Rican binder and a foundation of Nicaraguan fillers from Estelí, Condega, and Jalapa.

The result is a cigar that feels indulgent without becoming heavy. Every component was selected to create layers of sweetness, spice, and texture while maintaining balance from start to finish.

Even the presentation reflected the concept. Swiss Roll was packaged with artwork inspired by the Swiss franc, turning the cigar into both a collectible release and a memorable smoking experience.

Is it a grown-up Blue Cheese? Having smoked a couple of Swiss Rolls, yes and no. Yes, in that it’s certainly more refined than the Blue Cheese. But also no, because I think it’s a way better cigar. Mind you, that’s just my opinion, but I’ve smoked enough Blue Cheese sticks since they were first released to know the difference. I like them, and I always keep a couple in my humidor. But the Blue Cheese has AJ’s signature all over it. That’s not a bad thing, but it crosses into familiar territory: familiar enough that I sometimes get a been-there, done-that feeling about it.

On the other hand, the Swiss Roll goes the route of the Decenio or Amar. Like those cigars, it still has that AJ factory signature, but its execution displays a more playful, creative side of AJ Fernandez. Add to that the obvious long-term aging that Privada is known for, and you have a cigar far more sophisticated and complex than “grown-up Blue Cheese” suggests.

Every time I have one of these, I smile as I remove the cellophane, bronzed from long-term aging (sorry, my picture doesn’t capture just how bronze the cellophane is). That kind of discoloration can only happen with lots of time and under the right conditions. Obviously, Brian has figured out a combination of temperature and humidity that helps tease out the volatile aromatics from his cigars.

Sniffing the wrapper, I’m greeted by rich, floral sweetness combined with an almost salty, savory aroma reminiscent of a good steak. The foot gives off aromas of fresh-baked bread and dried fruit that remind me of a fine, luxe Champagne, like Cristal. The aromas could be a full meal!

The cold draw is perfect, with plenty of airflow and just the right amount of resistance. It’s as luxurious as the aromas, filled with bread, beer malt, and stone fruit. Simply lovely!

A heady mix of cedar, white pepper, sourdough, nougat, and caramel greets me on the first puff. Light coffee and black pepper follow, with a gentle, mouth-coating spice entering soon after. Luscious cream then arrives to soften the entire profile. And while nothing seems to coalesce into a core this early, there’s an implicit structure that organizes the profile. Nothing seems out of place.

As expected of many AJ sticks, coffee, cedar, and black pepper move to the center. These are joined by fresh-baked bread and malt. The cream envelops the flavors, while the spice provides an expansive pull on the profile to keep it from collapsing in on itself.

Around the one-inch mark, with the familiar AJ signature established, all bets are off as complexity hits like a hot-air popcorn popper: cardamom, nutmeg, cinnamon, allspice, salt, floral notes, vanilla, caramel, buttered popcorn, green and pink peppercorns. There’s more. I get fleeting glimpses of other flavors arising, but you get the point: this is complex as hell. The activity verges on chaos, but the core and cream provide a foundational presence that prevents the profile from going off the rails.

The sweet and creamy finish also helps anchor the activity. It’s not so much a structural element, but it provides a focal point between puffs that redirects my attention away from everything else happening. It’s a cool effect.

By the way, all that was in the first two inches.

The cigar maintains its high energy deep into the first half, though the cream thickens, leaving my mouth feeling like I just took a bite of cheesecake. I can feel the coffee trying to step forward through the swirl of secondary flavors.

As for strength, it’s medium. Any heavier and the profile would become as gravitational as a black hole. But the medium strength, combined with the gentle, expansive energy of the spice, gives the profile plenty of room for expression.

As I hit the halfway point, I look back on the first half. It has been almost like a kaleidoscope, constantly shifting within a fixed field of view. And while the high-energy activity continues, herbal notes enter in the form of sage and rosemary, accompanied by lemon and orange peel. Unlike the other secondary flavors, these don’t pop in and out; they act more like a secondary layer resting above the core. This gives the profile dimensionality and depth.

As I get deeper into the second half, I can feel the cigar loading as the draw tightens slightly. This darkens the profile and brings out a bit of nicotine. As expected, even that little bit of nicotine causes the profile to compress slightly. I gently roll the head of the cigar between my fingers to get the airflow going. The draw opens up, helping mitigate the compression.

The spice intensifies slightly. It still maintains that expansive energy, but it’s more pronounced at the front of my mouth. I can feel it pulling the profile forward. The movement is amazing.

By the final third, the profile is in a steady state. This is not to be mistaken for stasis. All the energy and movement are still present. It’s just not changing direction or shifting, and that’s fine with me. It allows me to simply enjoy the cigar’s goodness.

The nicotine hasn’t increased, but I can feel its cumulative effect as I enter a state of mild euphoria. The body is thick, velvety-smooth, and rich, and the strength is now medium-plus. I don’t feel any further compression, thanks to the spice, which continues its outward and forward pull.

The steady state doesn’t last for long.

With a couple of inches left, the spice moves to my lips, like it’s accelerating. At the same time, it becomes a little more pronounced in the back of my mouth, like a jet engine’s afterburner igniting. Another layer of sourdough bread and vanilla custard forms above the herbal-citrus peel layer. Amazing structure and movement!

I’m really loving the movement of the spice. The afterburners are off, and the spice is now moving all around the front of my mouth, like a jet maneuvering through a complex series of high-speed turns and twists. It reminds me of the canyon runs in Top Gun: Maverick.

As I reach the final inch, the veil of nicotine suddenly disappears, and I’m almost overwhelmed by the combined complexity of the profile and movement. Just when I think the profile has reached a comfortable plateau and offers some respite, the cigar seems to have other plans. These closing stages are as intense as buzzing canyons in an airplane. I’m now on full alert and on the edge of my seat, not knowing what to expect and ready to react to whatever comes my way.

The intensity of the experience should be enough to make me abandon the smoke, but it’s taking me back to my younger, adrenaline-junkie days: rock-hopping on a steep, off-trail ski slope, jumping off a platform fifty feet above a waterfall, or racing my car down a narrow mountain road. How I survived all that foolishness, I don’t know. But it sure was fun while I did it, and that sense of fun is what keeps me smoking this cigar.

I smoke it down to the nub. I’m a little disappointed that it’s ending. This has been such a fun cigar to smoke!

The layered structure of this profile is remarkable. The core stays recognizable beneath the herbal-citrus and sourdough-custard layers, while the spice keeps the whole profile expansive and in motion. Privada mentions layering in its description, but the way it comes together as a complete experience is amazing. The Blue Cheese may be familiar territory, but the Swiss Roll is one hell of a ride.


Wow! A Privada stick that isn’t hiding behind the membership wall! You can buy it from Privada directly, though several LCA shops carry it.


Discover more from Unco B's Stogie Diary

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

Welcome!

Cigars aren’t static.

They move, evolve, and reveal themselves over time.

This is a place to explore that experience—along with the people, ideas, and forces shaping the cigar world around it.

Explore the Diary!

Cigar Foundations
Cigar Reviews
Cigar Commentary

Let’s connect

Recent posts

My good friend Phil “Katman” Kohn! Read his blog!